A good majority of Christians all over India are protesting against the release of the movie, the Da Vinci Code! So, what is my opinion regarding the protests? A staunch Christian that I am, one might expect me to support those protesting against the release. ‘RUBBISH’ is what I’ll say. In fact, you might just find me protesting (if there was any) against the protestors of the release.
A few dignified Catholics formed a part of the censor committee to review the film and amongst them, were the Director of my institute (or should I say former?) XIC, Fr Myron Pereira and former Police Commissioner of Mumbai, Julio Rebeiro. The committee cleared the film minus any cuts only asking the producers to put up a disclaimer saying the film is purely fiction. Still, doubts lingered over the release as protests intensified. My questions to the protestors are these—
When Christian countries the world over including Italy and US didn’t have any objection, why India why? Why can’t we treat this as just a fictional story?
In fact, protestors have made sure that the film has got undue popularity although the reviews from Cannes Film Festival suggest that the film was disappointing. A lot more people who perhaps didn’t even know what the Da Vinci Code was all about would now want to watch the movie! Protests against Dan Brown’s book by the same name no doubt, increased its popularity. The fact that other Brown’s books weren’t as popular as the Code drives home this point. I recently finished reading the book and I must say that I wasn’t too impressed with it. The story sure was interesting and intriguing but I’m not sure if I admired the style of writing (and the ending I thought was slack). But there is another point to be noted here! Some people who read the book didn’t completely take it as fiction, which is why I agree with the censor board to add in a disclaimer. One of my brother’s friends, after reading the book commented in front of my bro, perhaps unaware that the latter was preacher’s son, “This is the end of Christianity man! Christianity ka toh waat lag gaya!” (or something along those lines) Because Mr. Brown mixed a lot of fiction with little facts, some were of the impression that what he wrote were only facts! Few people bother to turn the book and notice a portion of the bind which reads ‘Fiction’.
The foundation of Christianity wasn’t laid by a few mortal men who wrote the gospels and the rest of the Bible. It was laid by Someone who walked on this earth, performed miracles and died a criminal’s death only to be resurrected on the third day. How then can one think that this foundation will be shaken by a badly-made movie or a fictional book? Over the years, many such books have come out, some even claiming to be non-fiction, but not one was able to do any harm to the faith!
All I’ll say to those who object to the movie is, ‘If you don’t like the movie, then don’t watch it!’ It is as simple as that! Believe in the four gospels. Don’t make Dan Brown’s The Da Vinci Code, the fifth gospel! It (both the book and the movie) is after all just a fiction!
A few dignified Catholics formed a part of the censor committee to review the film and amongst them, were the Director of my institute (or should I say former?) XIC, Fr Myron Pereira and former Police Commissioner of Mumbai, Julio Rebeiro. The committee cleared the film minus any cuts only asking the producers to put up a disclaimer saying the film is purely fiction. Still, doubts lingered over the release as protests intensified. My questions to the protestors are these—
When Christian countries the world over including Italy and US didn’t have any objection, why India why? Why can’t we treat this as just a fictional story?
In fact, protestors have made sure that the film has got undue popularity although the reviews from Cannes Film Festival suggest that the film was disappointing. A lot more people who perhaps didn’t even know what the Da Vinci Code was all about would now want to watch the movie! Protests against Dan Brown’s book by the same name no doubt, increased its popularity. The fact that other Brown’s books weren’t as popular as the Code drives home this point. I recently finished reading the book and I must say that I wasn’t too impressed with it. The story sure was interesting and intriguing but I’m not sure if I admired the style of writing (and the ending I thought was slack). But there is another point to be noted here! Some people who read the book didn’t completely take it as fiction, which is why I agree with the censor board to add in a disclaimer. One of my brother’s friends, after reading the book commented in front of my bro, perhaps unaware that the latter was preacher’s son, “This is the end of Christianity man! Christianity ka toh waat lag gaya!” (or something along those lines) Because Mr. Brown mixed a lot of fiction with little facts, some were of the impression that what he wrote were only facts! Few people bother to turn the book and notice a portion of the bind which reads ‘Fiction’.
The foundation of Christianity wasn’t laid by a few mortal men who wrote the gospels and the rest of the Bible. It was laid by Someone who walked on this earth, performed miracles and died a criminal’s death only to be resurrected on the third day. How then can one think that this foundation will be shaken by a badly-made movie or a fictional book? Over the years, many such books have come out, some even claiming to be non-fiction, but not one was able to do any harm to the faith!
All I’ll say to those who object to the movie is, ‘If you don’t like the movie, then don’t watch it!’ It is as simple as that! Believe in the four gospels. Don’t make Dan Brown’s The Da Vinci Code, the fifth gospel! It (both the book and the movie) is after all just a fiction!
12 comments:
I agree with you...the book is badly written ( though the research is commendable) and from what I've read and heard about the movie...it is badly made. Why bother with protests? If you feel threatened by shoddy works your faith in yourself and your beliefs must be weak indeed, is what i say to the protestors.
BTW..read this review. It's hilarious!
http://movies2.nytimes.com/2006/05/18/movies/18code.html
Hey pooji... can u just post that url again... seemd to have gone out of the window...
Yea, i was little too kind to the movie sayin that ppl were 'disappointed' with the movie!!! From what I hear, 'disappointed' would be an understatement!!!
d o u b l e s p a c e d that i am, i shall now clear out my thoughts,
- u protest against a movie, i think u got too much time on ur hands
- u protest against a movie u haven't seen yet, i think u got too much time on ur hands
- apart from the time, i think its more the belief and as puj sed, the faith in one's own self and own religion. if u believe tht a book or film can shatter ur religion, then the better option wud b 2 stop following the religion n move on to something which u think is a lil stronger!
People who say "it's JUST fiction, so what's the big deal?" do not understand the effect such bad fiction as this can have. Uncritically-accepting people can 'go along' in their deep ignorance of historical fact, changing what they believe in order to conform with "the crowd." It's all about popularity with one's friends, isn't it? A new "common sense" which is in fact nonsensical arises, and sudddenly you have new prejudices becoming accepted as "truth" by mob assent. Remember what the crowds did to Jesus the week after they welcomed him into Jerusalem as their King, riding on a colt, laying palm fronds before him? Somewhere during that next week, a new "common sense" arose and became accepted by the masses as if it were "fact." The result amounted to a lynching ordered by Pilate's in his kangaroo court. That's historical fact even Dan Brown isn't greedy enough to dispute.
Several recent disturbing surveys have simultaneously shown about 60% of TDC readers have accepted Danny boy's weird tale in place of their former beliefs. Some 30% of people who have not read TDC but have "heard something about it" have changed their beliefs about Jesus and Mary Magdalene to conform their thinking to Dan Brown's premise. The movie will be a magnifying glass for some really uncritical people, especially those who come into the theater with the mob urge to foment a schoolyard fight.
The intelligent question is 'why' do they accept Dan Brown as the final authority offering all truth? A lot of people don't want to ask that question because it might interferes with their Catholic-bashing fun. Do they think the same 'bashing' way about non-Catholic Christians? About Jews? Muslims? Hindus?
The answer is about uncritical acceptance to conform with a mob mentality. "Uncle Tom's Cabin" and "The Protocols of the Elders of Zion" and the sequence in "Birth of a Nation" where the KKK saves the south from blacks are examples of works defended as "just" fiction. These fictional works can be directly shown to as responsible for societal changes of attitude -- so called "common sense" -- responsible for the racism and prejudice masquerading as "common sense" that drenched the 20th century in innocent blood. There is such a thing as good fiction and bad fiction. Don't be a cow wandering along to the slaughter. For heaven's sake, the normally anti-religious Slate.com is objecting to Dan Brown's lying cash grab. Indian authorities are wise to insist on a disclaimer to wake the "conforming cows" in society before they leave the theater and change their faiths to conform with the Gnostic Gospels according to Brown, SONY, Opie and Hanks.
I agree with u on a lot of points mate!! I did talk about ppl who do not accept this as just fiction... but when one creates this kinda negative popularity against any piece, ppl who didnt even know wat Da Vinci code is or who Dan Brown is, now knows abt the stuff discussed in that crappy book of his!!
I also mentioned... is our faith that weak that it will be shaken merely by a crappy piece of fiction or a badly made Hollywood movie???
I did talk about ppl who do not accept this as just fiction... but when one
If by "one" you mean "people insisting that historical truth be presented AS TRUTH, and not as a pack of lies simultaneously labelling itself with the word 'Novel' and the word 'Fact'", then count me as "one." Let your "yes" mean "yes" and your "no" mean "no," Dan Brown, SONY, Ron Howard and Tom Hanks.
creates this kinda negative popularity against any piece,
So what kind of popularity do you advocate creating for this "Da Vinci" crock? Positive popularity? Lies are lies. It doesn't matter what label you stick onto it. The problem comes from people un-critically trusting the label instead of the reality. The accidents instead of the substance. Didn't Jesus tell his apostles and disciples: "If you are not with me, you are against me."
ppl who didnt even know wat Da Vinci code is or who Dan Brown is, now knows abt the stuff discussed in that crappy book of his!!"
... and as I explained, they are using this book to change their beliefs with uncritical trust in the labelling. People who haven't even read the book are deciding to change their beliefs based on hearing "something" about it. That is the truly alarming part: People are changing the foundations of their faith because of a Doubleday book's popularity on the New York Rag Times bestseller list -- AND FOR NO OTHER REASON. Christians beter believe this deserves negative publicity. We are to "instruct the ignorant" and "counsel the doubtful." We are to speak the truth in season and out of season. You better get off that fence you're sitting on, brother.
This is a bottle of strychnine with a colourful label that says "Candy" on the outside: GIVEN AWAY FOR FREE TO EVERYONE. People are saying "I want to believe it's candy, so I will." I go back to my earlier question: what kind of publicity should such a thing have? Is the Indian Government behaving responsibly by putting the label "May be poisonous" over the "Candy" label from the manufacturer? N.B. this is NOT censorship, it is ensuring truth in advertising. One of the primary functions of a government is to protect its population from any attack. I believe the Indian Government has acted more responsibly in this case than every other government that has not required accurate labelling of this product.
I also mentioned... is our faith that weak that it will be shaken merely by a crappy piece of fiction or a badly made Hollywood movie???
Unfortunately, as I pointed out, the answer to this question is a resounding "YES." The question is what will those of us who understand the truth DO AND SAY about it? In the cases of 60% of those who read the book, and in 30% of those who merely "heard something about" the book, the answer has been repeatedly measured as "yes I have changed my faith to believe Jesus and Mary Magdalene had a child, etc." with accuracy +-1.5% 19 times out of 20 among representative sampling of adults aged 18-60 surveyed. That's only regarding the effect of the book. It has yet to be discovered what the parallel measurements are regarding the amplifying effect of the movie version.
Set your standard, choose your cause, stand on your side and speak the truth to everyone. The essence of evangelization is to tell everybody the truth.
Point taken sir!
But when u talk about Christianity's foundation/faith being weak, u need to check urself and think twice b4 makin a statement like that (or in ur case, u said a resounding Yes)... m sorry... but our faith was built on a Savior who died for us on the cross of calvary!!! So I totally disagree with u on that one!
M not here to debate with u and neither am i sitting on the fence NOR sir, m i influenced by any of my friends, as u seem to have mentioned in ur first comment. Lets go back and think abt wat Jesus did! Here he was standing surrounded by his accusers accusing all sort of mindless contradictions against him! But, did Jesus protest? Think about it! Our Savior was abused, insulted and humiliated BUT there was not a word of protest that Jesus raised! Then y should we, as followers of Christ, be annoyed by any morbid person that writes a book or makes a movie?
Also, u seem to have got me wrong on that negative popularity part... When u give something a negative popularity, it in turn makes that piece of more popular (as was the case in Da Vinci)! Protests leads to popularity sir! That is what I meant!
Also, u seemed to base ur opinion on some stats and figures drawn out of a survey.. well I am not too sure about that! And timeliness also matters!! The best thing at the moment, is NOT TO PROTEST BUT TO PRAY... That was one weapon which our Saviour has given us!!! and one POWERFUL weapon at that!! So, why protest, just PRAY!
U also talk about setting my standards and stand for the truth! Ahem sir, would u like to clarify what exactly do u mean by that? As in, when did i NOT stand for the truth? I am always for the Truth and that Truth is that Jesus Christ died for me and for you on the cross of calvary so that we could be saved and to give us eternal life. But he didnot remain in that grave! He rose again after the third day and HE is very much alive today and HE IS GOING TO COME BACK!!!
Hey,
I love d way you ended d piece. Very strong and intense. But as a journo ders some lack of objectivity thoh. But dats ok, since d topic is really close to ur heart so i guess its fine.
Mallu, this has been written by someone who in my opinion has the clearest view ever!!! I totally agree with you when you say that people do not know when fact ends and fiction begins. I never had thought about it that way. Really fantastic Mallu!!! Really love your style of writing!! And you have an even bigger fan in my Mom!!!
Hey u'r so very righthere. I couldnt believe so many protest going on in india o'er the movie and afterward on the book :) although the book was released first.Is christianity so weak that it can be shattered by a mere book..about fact centuries before written by a man of this century...who has seen nothing more than any one of us.
I saw the movie...too badly made...but worth the watchh...got to see places and churches all over the world..and paintingd too.
I dont think the book was that badly written...he did have a plot...I liked his mysterious style...but it wasnt not obvious that it was just a mere work of fiction...
i dont think this is ur fav..read thru this..so cmmnted!
preetha!
Enjoyed a lot! Weight training bodybuilding mitsubishi forklift 1992 chevrolet lumina apv minivan Computer for sale new Refinancing mortgage cost in bri Pontiac 3.1moter Search engine positioning saint paul Clark county wi camping Wal mart stock Golf gift bag St george car prices Accessory buy car uk car accidents or fatalities in arkansas car dealers used renault clio leeds Per marketing promotion strategy ppc pay click Medical malpractice regulation
Post a Comment